Sipe or Kosar?

I’ve been having this ongoing argument with a buddy of mine…who would you rather have as your QB in his prime? Brian Sipe or Bernie Kosar?

I’d take Bernie. Hard to argue with 3 AFC Championship game appearances. Sipe won an MVP, but Bernie had more great years than Sipe, and as for mobility, when Bernie was really hot, he was every bit as good as Peyton Manning or Dan Marino, both of whom are pretty immobile. In Browns history, there was nobody better at on-the-field command than Kosar. My buddy argues for Sipe, largely based on the MVP year of 1980.

Who would you take?

You can follow us on Twitter and Facebook for content updates.