Category: Cleveland Indians (Page 32 of 96)

The Indians returned from the break and seemed refreshed and re-energized as they used four homers to beat the Minnesota Twins 6-4 in the Metrodome Thursday night. Minnesota’s young pitching stud Francisco Liriano, the league’s ERA leader, was rocked for four earned runs in five innings pitched as he lost just his second game of the season. He may have edged out Travis Hafner for one of the final A.L All-Star spots, but Pronk got the better of Liriano this time, launching a solo home run to right field in the fifth inning. Liriano gave up three long balls on the night, including one to Casey Blake, who made his first return to the lineup after being out with an oblique strain. The Tribe added an insurance run in the ninth via Kelly Shoppach’s home run.

After allowing two straight walks to start the game, Cliff Lee settled down and gave up only two earned runs and five hits to notch his ninth win of the season. He has now won six of his last seven decisions dating back to early June. Fausto Carmona, who continues to dominate as a setup man, pitched another scoreless eighth and Bob Wickman saved his 14th of the season.

If Mark Shapiro hasn’t been feeling pressure to cut the cord on Aaron Boone and call up slick-fielding, power-hitting third baseman Andy Marte from Buffalo as his replacement, he will after last night’s Triple-A All Star Home Run Derby:

When the best power hitters in Triple-A baseball were finished, a number of balls had left the park and pounded onto the pavement beyond the high barricade in left field. Andy Marte of the Buffalo Bisons, a top prospect in the Cleveland system, won the competition by hitting 29 home runs, and as shot after shot disappeared into the night sky, Tribe fans had to be saying: “Get this guy to Cleveland.”

Um…yeah. As I stated in a previous post, it’s got to be difficult to make such a move (replacing an established, albeit struggling, veteran with an unproven prospect) because it signals the end of your season (most likely), but enough is enough. At the very least, Marte can’t possibly be any worse than Boone, although some readers recently have commented on the effects of team chemistry, and losing Boone would certainly change the chemistry. Still, Marte is a very good defensive third baseman and, obviously, the kid can hit.

Now, let’s see him do it at the Jake.

At the young age of 23, Indians outfielder Grady Sizemore has been invited to his very first MLB All-Star Game. Sizemore, who enters the break batting .291 with 15 home runs and 43 RBI, will be the Indians’ lone representative for the American League team. In addition, he also leads the league in runs scored and extra-base hits. It’s been a disappointing season thus far for Grady’s Tribe, but Indians fans can be proud of his accomplishments and his All-Star selection.

Ever since he broke into the majors, Sizemore has become a fan favorite in Cleveland because of his constant hustle on the field. He’s an extremely talented athlete, one who almost went to the University of Washington on a football scholarship. The Indians are happy he made the right decision by sticking to baseball. They got him, along with Cliff Lee and Brandon Phillips, from Montreal in a 2002 trade for Bartolo Colon. With his athletic ability and all-out playing style, it’s easy to see why the Indians were so high on this kid at the time. Four years later, Grady is an All-Star and one of the center pieces of the Indians’ future. He may be a laid-back guy off the field, but once he steps on the baseball diamond, Sizemore plays every game like it’s his last.

“I like to play that way,” he said. “I like to give it my all every day. I just love being a baseball player. It’s a great job to have. I wouldn’t have it any other way – to get to compete at the professional level every day.”

Indians third base coach Jeff Datz loves what Sizemore brings to the table.

“He can impact the game in so many ways,” said Datz. “He’s in scoring position when he’s at the plate because he can hit one out at anytime. Or he can hit one into the gap for a double or triple. If he hits a single or walks, he can steal second. He can take away base hits in the outfield with his speed and his glove. He’s absolutely fearless in the outfield. He’ll run into walls to catch a ball. He doesn’t care. And he’s so smart he always knows where to position himself. I rarely have to move him.”

In today’s modern era, it’s refreshing to see an athlete who puts the money and fame secondary to the love of the game. Grady, with his long-term deal, is financially set for awhile but does not let that get in the way of his play on the field. So many times we see athletes in all sports relax and dog it once they land that big-money contract. But not Grady. Tribe fans can’t help but be excited about the attitude of this kid. He plays hard to the final out and is a tremendous talent in the batter’s box as well as in center field. At 23, Grady will undoubtedly find himself in plenty more All-Star Games for the rest of his career.

Judging by some of the comments I’ve seen here, it seems a lot of people are holding Mark Shapiro accountable for the Tribe’s problems this year. It’s nice to see that most of us, as evidenced by our current poll, believe the players are more to blame than the front office but, nonetheless, several readers have been griping about some of Shapiro’s moves heading into the season. Specifically, Brandon Phillips, Coco Crisp, Kevin Millwood and Bob Howry.

First, Phillips, who’s having an exceptional rookie season for the Reds, hitting .306 with 7 homers, 44 RBI and 16 steals in 17 attempts. Would it be nice to have him doing that up north instead? Absolutely, but where were the Indians going to play him? In place of Belliard? Peralta? No. There was NO ROOM for Phillips here, and while it’s easy to say Shapiro screwed up now that he’s playing so well in Cincinnati, Phillips gave the Tribe absolutely no reason to include him in their long-term plans. They’d been waiting for him to develop for years and this spring, because he was out of options and therefore couldn’t be sent back to the minors, they were faced with a tough choice with Phillips. Had they kept him, he would’ve played maybe once a week in a utility role, and I can guarantee with that kind of activity he wouldn’t be hitting the ball the way he is now in a starting role with the Reds.

In fact, people are whining about Coco (still) but why are they so bitter about that trade? Because the Tribe gave up a good major leaguer for a great minor leaguer? So what, should the Indians have benched/traded/released Belliard or Peralta to make room for a guy who never showed any production within the system and reportedly never made much of an effort to improve? How much sense does that make, and how much heat would Shapiro have taken (from the same people bitching about the Coco trade) for getting rid of a productive major leaguer for an unproven kid? Sure, it would’ve been nice to see them get more for Phillips but, the fact of the matter is, he wasn’t WORTH more at the time. The Reds rolled the dice and it paid off for them. If the Indians had kept Phillips, he’d be wasting away on their bench or they would’ve cut him by now anyway. Either way, his breakthrough season wasn’t happening in Cleveland. Get over it.

As for Coco, wow, a quick look at his numbers tells me he really would’ve made a difference this season:

Crisp: 183 AB, .268, 4 HR, 14 RBI, 8 SB, .313 OBP

How do those stellar stats compare to Coco’s replacement in left and in the second spot in the lineup, Jason Michaels?

Michaels: 265 AB, .268, 6 HR, 26 RBI, 5 SB, .330 OBP

Granted, Coco missed several weeks with a broken knuckle and Michaels hasn’t been the on-base machine that he was advertised to be, but these guys look pretty damn interchangeable to me. People cited an expected jump in Coco’s power numbers as one of the reasons they objected to the trade but it’s obvious he hasn’t been doing much of anything for the Sox. In fact, Boston moved him out of the leadoff slot and now has him hitting in the bottom third of the order. Would the numbers look different if Coco was still in Cleveland? Probably. But at the same time, it seems pretty clear to me that he’s not the kind of “irreplaceable” player many fans claimed (and still claim, apparently) he was at the time of the deal.

How about Millwood and Howry? Well, it’s tough to really gauge the Howry situation. The Cubs agreed to pay him $12 million over three years, which is pretty steep for a set-up guy. Still, looking at the Indians’ bullpen woes this year, it’s all too easy to say things would be different if the Tribe had kept Howry. He’s won three games for the Cubs, saved two, struck out 40 batters in 43 innings and sports a 3.12 ERA. Would those numbers look nice in the eighth inning here? Absolutely, especially considering the problems Guillermo Mota and Fernando Cabrera have had this year. But relievers can be very difficult to predict from one year to the next. For proof, check out Cabrera’s numbers last year to his numbers this year (2-1, 1.47 ERA, 29 strikeouts in 30 innings / 1-1, 6.46 ERA, 33 strikeouts [and 20 walks] in 30 innings), or Mota’s from 2004 to Mota’s in 2005 (9-8, 3.07 ERA, 85 strikeouts in 96 innings / 2-2, 4.70 ERA, 60 strikeouts in 67 innings), or Howry’s from 2002 to his next healthy season in 2004 with the Tribe (3-5, 4.19 ERA, 45 strikeouts in 68 innings / 4-2, 2.74 ERA, 39 strikeouts in 42 innings). As we’ve seen, your bullpen can be great one year and awful the next, and that’s because relievers can be great one year and awful the next. Putting $4 million a year into a 32-year-old reliever with a history of arm problems wasn’t the right move last November and it isn’t the right move now.

And speaking of giving too much money to aging pitchers with lengthy injury histories, as much as I wanted the Indians to resign Millwood, and as much as I wasn’t thrilled with the Paul Byrd signing to replace Millwood, again, letting the Rangers give him $60 million over five years was without question the right move. Shall we look at the numbers?

Millwood: 8-5, 4.83 ERA, 134 hits and 75 strikeouts in 110 innings pitched
Byrd: 6-6, 4.31 ERA, 112 hits and 59 strikeouts in 102 innings pitched

Again, pretty damn interchangeable. Would having Millwood instead of Byrd have us competing with the Tigers and White Sox in the Central? For that matter, would having Millwood, Coco, Howry and Phillips have us up there? Maybe we’re a little better than 40-47 at this point, but not much. In fact, the only one out of this group who conceivably, when comparing the numbers, would’ve made much of a difference this year is Howry, and at the end of the day, how many wins is one reliever worth?

So while it may be easy to pin this lost season on the front office in general and Shapiro in particular, let’s get real. There’s more than enough talent on this roster for the team to be at least 10 games higher in the standings, but they’re not living up to that potential. Before you go blaming Shapiro for this mess, let’s not forget that he’s the one who went out and got Travis Hafner, Grady Sizemore and Cliff Lee, among others. He built this team back into contention several years sooner than anyone thought possible. He’s avoided getting stuck with awful contracts (Millwood and Thome, to name two). If there’s one thing I can blame him for, it’s sticking with Aaron Boone this long rather than calling up Andy Marte, but doing that raises the white flag on 2006 and I imagine that’s a tough thing to do when you’re talking about a team whose talent isn’t translating into wins.

A couple of late inning wild pitches and a passed ball proved to be the difference as the Orioles edged the Indians 5-4 in the series finale. The game consisted of several misplays by both teams but it was those committed by the Tribe that were more costly. The Indians took an early 4-1 lead in the second inning as a result of a misjudged fly ball by Corey Patterson, a Brain Roberts error, and a Rodrigo Lopez wild pitch. Jake Westbrook left with the lead but the bullpen failed to preserve it. The Orioles got their late-game runs by way of a Rafael Perez wild pitch in the seventh and a Victor Martinez passed ball in the eighth. The Indians stumble into the All-Star break with a 40-47 record and sit 16.5 games behind the AL wild card-leading Chicago White Sox.

“I want everyone to go home and reflect and be honest with themselves,” Eric Wedge said. “I want them to look in the mirror. I want them to be thick-skinned about what they’ve done and what they need to do to get better individually.”

The break should also give GM Mark Shapiro some time to reflect on the state of the team and the moves they should soon be making. There’s absolutely no reason why we shouldn’t see Andy Marte’s face in Cleveland by the trading deadline.